Showing posts with label Workers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Workers. Show all posts

Thursday, September 21, 2017

The Fallacy of the Bootstrap Gospel


Matthew 20:1-16
“That’s not fair!” It’s something cried out in the playground every day.
“That’s not fair.” Something mumbled at the dinner table when brother gets a bigger piece of the much loved lasagna, or when sister gets a smaller piece of the much disliked broccoli.
“That’s not fair” words tumbling out of the mouth of a student who slaved over a paper only to learn that another student got an extension.
“That’s not fair” thrown about in the breakroom when talking about another person’s promotion, perhaps one you felt you deserved.
To quote my father, and I would guess most of your father’s “Life is not fair.”
Only, we expect it to be, don’t we? We expect to get from life what we put into it, and we expect others to be rewarded the same way. That is part of what our American, pull yourself up by your own bootstraps, mentality runs on; the premise that if we work hard enough, do the right things, then we can all arrive at the same destination.
And perhaps that’s what makes this morning’s teaching so displeasing, uncomfortable, down right yucky. I have even heard that there are people who avoid coming to church on the Sunday this story comes up in the lectionary. They dislike it that much!
Jesus is teaching, talking really, to his disciples and he again picks up this theme of the kingdom of heaven is like. . .
We’ve heard these phrases, the kingdom of heaven is like a mustard seed.
-the kingdom of heaven is like a shepherd looking for a lost sheep.
-the kingdom of heaven is like a woman searching her whole house for one coin.
- the kingdom of heaven is like yeast
- the kingdom of heaven is like a treasure buried in a field.
Here we get the kingdom of heaven is like a landowner who went out early in the morning. . .
With all of these kingdom of heaven phrases we have a tendency to take some literal interpretation. God is the landowner, we are the servants. God is the shepherd we are the sheep, God is the woman we are the coin (or perhaps that’s a bit of a stretch)
There is a huge problem reading these passages in this manner. Not one of these parables, in fact not all of the parables put together, actually describe the literal kingdom of heaven. Not one! Not all! Parables are comparisons, they are stories, and they are used to illustrate an idea, a concept that we really have no words to describe.
When we say March came in like a Lion and out like a Lamb, do we literally mean that the beginning of the month of March started with a lion coming down the streets and ended with a lamb walking away? Of course not. We mean the weather was rough at the beginning and calm at the end.
That is what parables do, they explain an idea or concept, not the actual kingdom of God. A picture is worth a thousand words, and parables give us a picture, a glimpse into the upside down, tables turned kingdom of God.
There was a landowner who went out in the morning to hire workers in his fields. And right off we have something that should cause us to pause. Landowners didn’t hire their workers, managers hired the workers. What was this landowner doing out in the marketplace looking for workers himself? That’s odd. His HR person should be holding interviews for him.
He finds workers, agrees to the normal day’s pay for a normal day’s work and sends them on to his fields. He’s a just landowner, he doesn’t try to cheat them; he agrees to pay the daily rate, not more, but certainly not less. The workers agree and go on to their jobs.
Later in the day the landowner goes out again and finds people waiting for work. I don’t know how many of you have experience with this, but growing up in Lubbock, Texas I remember groups of men, usually Latin American men, would gather outside of the local hardware store that my bus drove past on the way to school each morning. Construction foreman would pull up in their company trucks and load as many workers as they needed into the back of the truck, with promises of a day’s pay.
Driving home past that same hardware store there were occasionally still people standing around at 4pm. They looked tired, desperate, some older, some more frail, but still waiting for someone to hire them.
This landowner goes out at 9 am and hires a group of workers and agrees to pay them what is fair, or right, or just. Then he is out again at noon, then three with the same offer. And then at 5 pm he goes and finds people still waiting to be hired and says “Why are you here not working?” And they respond “Well I slept in too late.” “Well I didn’t feel like working this morning.” “Well, my parents didn’t teach me how to fill out the proper paperwork to get a job.” “Well I’m freeloading.”
No; they respond “no one has hired us.” Plain and simple. They have been waiting for a job and none has been provided. And so the landowner sends them on for the last hour of work. He doesn’t even promise them a fair wage, just an hours’ worth of work. But an hours’ worth is better than nothing, and so they go.
An hour later the owner calls to his manager (he has a manager, so why was he hunting down workers) and has him gather the workers to be paid beginning with the last and going to the first.
Everyone who has lined up for kindergarten or concert tickets or Black Friday specials knows that this is NOT how things are done. First come, first served. But that is not the way this landowner chooses to act.
The last shall be first, it didn’t endear him to his workers then, it wouldn’t endear him now.
They workers begin receiving their pay. Those who worked an hour received a day’s wage. The gossip spread to the back of the line. “If they worked and hour and got that much, imagine how much we will get.” They begin to think. And as they received their wages, their faces fell. They received a day’s wage for a day’s work.
It was exactly what had been promised. They had agreed to it in the early hours of the morning. But now it was not enough. Now they felt cheated. Now they felt taken advantage of.
Why? They made a contract and it was honored. Why feel put out, angry, cheated?
The landowner replies “Why are you upset? I paid you what was due. Are you envious because I am generous?”
Yes
Yes, they are envious. And yes we often are as well. It isn’t so much that other people get things from God that we don’t get. It’s not that they got more or better rewards. The problem seems to be that they got the same, and they don’t deserve it.
That’s the issue these workers have. They did the work, so they deserve the day’s wage. The other’s didn’t do as much, as hard, as good what have you work and therefore shouldn’t get the same things.
It’s not that they have been cheated, they got exactly what they had originally expected. It’s that others got the same amount. “You have made them equal to us.” Is their response.
Dr. Ira Brent Driggers, an Associate Professor at Lutheran Theological Seminary puts it this way “Even the workers hired early in the morning . . . roll out of bed unemployed. But the owner finds them and gives them work. I imagine they were, no less than the nine o’clock hires ‘standing idle in the marketplace.’ Whatever they were doing, it wasn’t working. There was no real livelihood prior to the owner seeking them out. But by the end of the day they seem to have forgotten this. Or maybe they never really understood. What is clear is that, come payment time, they are thinking only in terms of just reward. Pay must be commensurate with the hours worked – as if the work itself was not the real ‘reward.’”[i]
The workers do not recognize the gift of grace they have received in order to have work in the first place. They have become convinced that they are being treated unfairly because other’s received the same amount. And so the landowner asks “Are you envious because I am generous.”
Rev. Doctor Emerson Powery says the landowner’s question, “Are you envious because I am generous?” (verse 15), is the translation of a Greek idiom which literally translates as “Is your eye evil because I am good?” An “evil eye” (ophthalmos poneros) suggested a deeper problem than meets the eye. As Jesus taught earlier, “The eye is the lamp of the body. So, if your eye is healthy, your whole body will be full of light; but if your eye is unhealthy (ophthalmos poneros; so, if you have the “evil eye”), your whole body will be full of darkness” (cf. 6:22-23). In this account, the “evil eye” was the opposite of generosity (e.g., jealousy, greed, stinginess, etc.).[ii]
Viewing someone else’s good fortune as our demotion is ridiculous at best, and evil at worst. We have not earned our place as children of God, we can’t do that. It is grace, a gift, unmerited favor. Yet there are those who would act as if they somehow deserve their standing with God. I think that Matthew shares this parable to remind us that whether we are 7th generation Christian, or just walked in off the street to hear the Gospel for the first time, our status is the same, laborer for God, child of the king, beloved.
Who do you identify with in the parable? The laborers who worked all day, received enough to feed their families, and yet feel cheated? The workers who were only there an hour and yet were blessed with enough to feed their families?
How we see this parable tells us a lot about how we see our role in the kingdom of God. “Faced with God's boundless love for the world, especially when it is lavished upon others, we reveal whether we view our own labor as a gift from God or as benefit to God, as the joyful fulfillment of our created purpose or as the mere endurance of scorching heat.”[iii]
The Gospel Truth is that we are all equal recipients of God’s gifts. The truth in our hearts is that sometimes we are jealous when such gifts are shared with others in equal measure.
To quote the great theologian Louis CK,
“The only time you look in your neighbor's bowl is to make sure that they have enough. You don't look in your neighbor's bowl to see if you have as much as them.”
The kingdom of heaven, my friends, is like a generous landowner, who went out every hour seeking to give people a job, a calling, a vocation; and never stopped seeking even when there was little time left to work. And then gave them all enough to feed themselves and their families.  Let us not be evil eyed toward the gifts other’s receive. Let us rejoice that they too have their daily bread.




[i] Ira Brent Driggers Working Preacher September 21, 2008
[ii] The Reverend Doctor Emerson Powery, Working Preacher September 21, 2014
[iii] Ira Brent Driggers Working Preacher September 21, 2008

Thursday, March 2, 2017

Day 30: Dreamers and Workers

Genesis 31,32 & Matthew 20:1-16

Sometimes we make delineations between Dreamers and Workers. Dreamers, we tend to think, are those who waste their time waiting for things to come to them. Workers, on the other hand, are seen as salt of the earth type people. In the scriptures for today we get a different take on dreamers and workers.

Genesis 31:

God tells Jacob that the times has come to return to the land of his father Isaac. In a dream, God shows Jacob that all he has amassed has been because of God’s blessing. It is now time to take that blessing and return home. Jacob tells his wives of this revelation and they agree to go with Jacob stating that there is nothing left for them in their father’s house.
Rachel gathers up her things to leave and takes some extra souvenirs, her father’s household gods. These were totems of gods said to be a blessing to the household. They were often used in divination and were important to the inheritance system. Perhaps Rachel wanted to assure her family of these blessings, or keep her father from going to the gods to find out where they were heading.
Laban learns of their sneaking away and catches up to the group seven days later (again with the seven!) God speaks to Laban in a dream telling him to speak neither good nor bad to Jacob when he confronts him. Laban tells Jacob of his conversation with God. He also asks where his household gods have gone. Jacob, not knowing Rachel has stolen them, says he will put to death anyone found with the gods. After a thorough search, everywhere except Rachel’s saddlebags, the gods are not found.  Jacob tells Laban that twenty years of servitude is more than enough.
The two men make a peace between them and set up a pillar of stones. Neither will pass with the intention of harming the other, as God is their witness. Laban lets Jacob keep the flocks, women and children. Jacob agrees to not harm them and to take no other wives.

Genesis 32:

The last time Jacob had seen his brother Esau, some twenty years ago, Esau had been ready to murder Jacob. With this thought in mind, Jacob sends word to his brother that he is coming. Jacob’s messenger returns saying Esau is coming to meet Jacob, with a delegation of 400 men. Jacob fears a massacre.
Jacob divides his group in two camps in hopes of saving at least half of what he has. Jacob prays to God for help. He recites again the promises God made. This is an example of praying scripture. While God’s promise has not yet been written down, it has been spoken. Jacob is reminding himself of God’s word. Something we all should do especially in times of trial.
He culls his herds and sends out hundreds of goats, sheep, camels, cows, and donkeys. Jacob has them keep space between them, hoping that five separate herds as gifts might soften the blow of his return.
Then Jacob does the unthinkable. He sends his whole family across the Euphrates River and goes back to the other side. He waits there overnight by himself. Jacob wrestles with a man there all night long. He refuses to let go until the man gives him a blessing. The man changes Jacobs name from Jacob to Israel meaning one who struggles with God and overcame.
Was it a literal wrestling match? Or was that a metaphor for Jacob’s dark night of the soul? Given what we have seen of Jacob’s character it is quite possible he was considering running away and saving his own skin. Historically this has been Jacob’s MO. But here, he battles with God and overcomes his fears. He moves on remembering God’s promise.

Matthew 20:1-16

Have you ever met someone who felt they had “special status” in the church? You know who I mean, right? Those that trace their heritage back four or more generations, or that claim their family pew has been occupied longer than any other? Have you ever been that person yourself?
This parable is about God’s grace. God has given us all grace through Jesus Christ. It is the SAME grace regardless of when we experienced it for the first time.
The Pharisees and Sadducees claimed a special place in God’s kingdom. Some claimed it due to lineage, others due to their excellent rule following. They were upset when Jesus was offering common riffraff the same or equal status in the kingdom of God. It was viewed as unfair at the least. Jesus points out here that God never gives less than is promised and God’s generosity to others is not to be called into question.